TenX Investment

Home › Blog

SIPs

The Nifty is still below where it began 2026. A monthly SIP in it is not

By Prateek Gupta, CA, CS, 15 Nov 2026, 5 min read

On 1 January 2026 the Nifty 50 closed at 26,146.55. On 13 November it closed at 25,144.30, which is 3.8% lower. In between it fell as much as 15.6% from its record, to 22,231.80 on 8 October, and then won most of that back in five weeks.

Take two people with the same ₹1,10,000. One put all of it into the index on New Year's Day. The other put in ₹10,000 on the first trading day of each month. On 13 November the first has ₹1,05,783. The second has ₹1,15,139.

The Nifty 50 in 2026, and the eleven days the SIP bought

22,00023,00024,00025,00026,000JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovRecord: 26,329 on 2 JanLow: 22,232 on 8 Oct13 Nov close: 25,144 22,00023,00024,00025,00026,000JanAprJulOctRecord: 26,329Low: 22,23213 Nov close: 25,144

Bought below the 13 November close (10)Bought above it (1)

Closing level of the Nifty 50 on each trading day from 1 January to 13 November 2026. The dots are the first trading day of each month. Source: NSE.

Eleven purchases, ten of them below today's level

The reason is not clever timing. The monthly investor kept buying while prices were low, and so got more for the same ₹10,000.

InstalmentNifty 50 that dayWorth on 13 Nov
1 Jan26,146.55₹9,617
1 Feb24,825.45₹10,128
2 Mar24,865.70₹10,112
1 Apr22,679.40₹11,087
4 May24,119.30₹10,425
1 Jun23,382.60₹10,753
1 Jul24,005.85₹10,474
3 Aug24,774.30₹10,149
1 Sep24,055.80₹10,452
1 Oct22,421.95₹11,214
2 Nov23,440.80₹10,727
₹1,10,000 put in, now worth₹1,15,139

Only the January instalment was bought above today's level. The two that have done best are April's and October's, the two bought nearest the bottom.

The day it looked worst

On 8 October, the low of the year, the monthly investor had put in ₹1,00,000 and it was worth ₹92,318, a loss of 7.7%. The New Year lump sum was down 15.0%. The SIP did not prevent a loss. It made the loss smaller, and it meant ten purchases had been made on the way down.

What stopping would have cost

March was the hardest month: the Nifty fell 11.3%. Suppose the monthly investor had stopped there. The three instalments already made, ₹30,000, would be worth ₹29,857 today, about where they started. The eight made from April onwards, ₹80,000, are worth ₹85,282. All of this year's gain came from the instalments made after the fall, which are the hardest ones to make.

When the lump sum wins

None of this makes a SIP the better way to invest in general. It did better this year because the market fell first and recovered later. When a market rises through the year, money put in at the start has longer to grow, and the lump sum wins.

We checked the twenty calendar years from 2006 to 2025, using the Nifty 50 with dividends added back. The January lump sum finished the year ahead of twelve monthly instalments in fifteen of them. The SIP finished ahead in five: 2008, 2011, 2013, 2020 and 2022, each a year in which the market fell for part of the way.

Most people do not choose between the two anyway. A lump sum needs the money on 1 January. A SIP needs a salary.

What the example leaves out

  • The Nifty 50 is an index, and nobody can buy an index directly. An index fund follows it less its costs, and can drift from it slightly.
  • Dividends are left out of the figures above. With them added back, the lump sum is down 2.9% and the SIP is up 5.3%.
  • Stamp duty and tax are ignored.
  • It is one index over eleven months. Had the market kept falling after October, both investors would be in loss today.

A SIP does not assure a profit or protect against a loss in a falling market. What it does is keep you buying when buying feels wrong, and this year that was worth about ₹9,400 on ₹1,10,000.

For the same idea in a three-month example, see Why your SIP works hardest when markets fall. To see how a SIP started in any month since 2000 has done, open Charts since 2000.

Sources: NSE closing levels of the Nifty 50 and the Nifty 50 Total Returns Index, 1 January to 13 November 2026 and calendar years 2006 to 2025; TenX calculations. An illustration of the past, before costs and tax. Not a forecast or a recommendation.

For general information and education only, not investment advice or a recommendation. Mutual Fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.

More from the blog