TenX Investment

Money Stories · No. 6 · 15 November 2026 · 9 min read

The ₹40 lakh question: prepay the home loan or keep the SIP going?

Debjit and Tania owe ₹40 lakh on their flat in Behala, with 15 years to go, and have ₹20,000 left over every month. Her father says clear the loan first. His colleague says the market pays more than the bank charges. We followed both for 15 years. One road is loan-free in 7 years 8 months. The other ends ₹13 lakh richer, on paper. Then we tried to break each one.

The loan as it stands

Debjit and Tania Ghosh bought their 2BHK in Behala, Kolkata, five years ago. What remains of the loan is ₹40 lakh at 8.5%, on a floating rate, with 15 years left. The EMI is ₹39,390. If they change nothing, they will pay the bank ₹70.90 lakh over those 15 years: the ₹40 lakh they owe and ₹30.90 lakh of interest.

After the EMI and the household budget, ₹20,000 is left every month. The question is where it should go.

Two roads, the same ₹59,390 a month

On both roads the same amount leaves their account each month: ₹39,390 of EMI plus ₹20,000. Only the destination of the ₹20,000 differs.

Road A: prepay first

₹20,000 extra to the loan

  • Loan closed in 7 years 8 months
  • Interest paid: ₹14.55 lakh, a saving of ₹16.35 lakh
  • Then the whole ₹59,390 goes into a SIP for 7 years 4 months
  • ₹82.08 lakh at year 15

Road B: SIP alongside

₹20,000 a month into a SIP

  • Loan runs the full 15 years
  • Interest paid: ₹30.90 lakh
  • 180 instalments of ₹20,000
  • ₹95.19 lakh at year 15

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →

End of yearRoad A: loan leftRoad A: fundRoad B: loan leftRoad B: fund
1₹36.12 L–₹38.62 L₹2.55 L
3₹27.32 L–₹35.48 L₹8.62 L
5₹16.88 L–₹31.77 L₹16.22 L
7₹4.52 L–₹27.37 L₹25.76 L
8Closed₹2.52 L₹24.87 L₹31.40 L
10–₹19.24 L₹19.20 L₹44.81 L
12–₹40.21 L₹12.48 L₹61.62 L
15–₹82.08 LClosed₹95.19 L

Before tax. Fund at an assumed 12% a year, compounded monthly; loan at 8.5% throughout. L = lakh.

Road B ends ₹13.11 lakh ahead. The reason is plain: the SIP is assumed to earn 12% while the loan costs 8.5%, and every rupee that stays invested earns the difference for longer.

The table holds a second thing. In the month Road A makes its last loan payment, 7 years 8 months in, Road B's fund stands at ₹29.45 lakh and its loan at ₹25.73 lakh. Road B could clear its loan that day as well, if it chose to. Until then it has carried a loan and a market risk together.

Prepaying is a sure 8.5%. The SIP is a hoped-for 12%. The whole question is how much that hope is worth to you.

What can go wrong on each road

A steady 12% is an average, not a path. We changed one thing at a time:

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →

If…Road A: prepay firstRoad B: SIP alongside
The fund earns a steady 12%₹82.08 L₹95.19 L
It earns a steady 10%₹76.12 L₹80.32 L
It earns a steady 8%₹70.61 L₹67.96 L
It earns a steady 6%₹65.50 L₹57.66 L
12%, but markets fall 30% in year 8₹81.54 L₹70.02 L
12%, but markets fall 30% in year 15₹52.46 L₹59.88 L
The loan rate rises to 9.5%, fund at 12%₹86.36 L₹95.19 L

Two rows matter most. The first is the break-even: a fund return of about 8.8% a year. Below that, prepaying wins.

The second is the fall in year 8. By then Road B has ₹26 lakh in the market and Road A has nothing there, so the fall hits only one of them, and Road A finishes ₹11.52 lakh ahead. The same fall in year 15 hits both, and Road B stays in front.

There is also a risk no table shows. On Road A the EMI disappears after 7 years 8 months. If one of them loses a job in year 9, there is no loan to service. On Road B the ₹39,390 is due every month for 15 years, whatever happens to their salaries or the market.

Tax moves the line a little

On the fund. Gains on equity funds held for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year. If each road sold everything in year 15, Road B would pay about ₹7.24 lakh and Road A about ₹3.56 lakh. Road B's lead shrinks from ₹13.11 lakh to ₹9.43 lakh, and the break-even return rises from 8.8% to about 9.5%. Selling over several years, rather than all at once, would cut both bills.

On the loan. Under the old tax regime, interest on a loan for a home you live in can be deducted, up to ₹2 lakh a year. Debjit and Tania will pay ₹3.35 lakh of interest in the coming year, so at the highest slab the deduction is worth up to ₹62,400 a year. It makes the loan cheaper than 8.5% for as long as they claim it. Under the new regime there is no such deduction and the loan costs the full 8.5%. So prepaying is worth more to a family in the new regime than in the old.

A middle road

They don't have to pick one. If ₹10,000 goes to the loan and ₹10,000 to a SIP, the loan closes in 10 years 1 month, the interest bill is ₹19.66 lakh, and they have ₹86.97 lakh at year 15: between the two roads on every count.

  1. An emergency fund comes before either. Money prepaid into a loan can't be taken back out when a salary stops. For its first 7 years 8 months, Road A has no savings to fall back on at all.
  2. Windfalls do the most in the early years. A bonus paid into the loan cuts the most interest while the balance is at its largest. Banks cannot charge a penalty for prepaying a floating-rate home loan taken by an individual.
  3. Road B only works if the SIP is never skipped. A prepayment happens once and stays done. A SIP has to survive 180 monthly decisions, some of them made in falling markets.

Prepay or SIP calculator: where should the spare money go?

Move the sliders. Everything updates instantly and stays on your device.

Road A: all to the loan first

Road B: all to a SIP

Your split

Road A: prepay firstRoad B: SIP alongsideYour splitEach line is the fund's value minus the loan still owed

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →

End of yearRoad A: loan leftRoad A: fundRoad B: loan leftRoad B: fund

How it works: every month the same amount leaves the account on each road, the EMI plus the spare money. The loan charges interest monthly on what is owed. Whatever part of the month's amount is not paid to the loan goes into the fund at the start of the month and grows at the chosen yearly return, compounded monthly. On Road A the spare money prepays the loan until it closes, and from then on the EMI and the spare money both go to the fund. With the tax switch on, 12.5% is taken on the fund's gain above ₹1.25 lakh, as if everything were sold in the last year. With the fall switched on, the fund returns −30% in the year named. Fund costs are assumed to be inside the return. Not a forecast or a recommendation.

What these numbers don't show

Floating rates float. The loan's 8.5% will move with RBI policy over 15 years. A higher rate makes prepaying more valuable, and a lower one makes it less so.

Peace of mind has no column. Many families simply sleep better without a loan. That is a real return, even though a calculator can't price it.

A fund can be sold; a prepayment can't be undone. Units can be turned into cash in a few working days. Equity in a flat can't pay a hospital bill or a college fee.

Returns arrive in lumps. Fifteen years of 12% will not look like the smooth line in the chart. Road B's family has to hold on through the bad years to get the average.

How this choice changes other decisions

Retirement. On Road A the family begins investing eight years later. Story No. 5 shows what a late start costs: the same goal needs a much larger monthly amount.

Children's education. If a child's college falls inside these 15 years, a fund can pay the fees and a paid-off flat can't. Story No. 7 works through that bill.

The next loan. A closed home loan makes a car or education loan easier to get. A ₹30 lakh fund can make one unnecessary.

Debjit and Tania's plan: six months of expenses set aside first, then ₹10,000 to the loan and ₹10,000 to a SIP, with each year's bonus going to the loan.

Prepay or invest: frequently asked questions

Should I prepay my home loan or invest in a SIP?

It depends on what the investment earns after tax compared with the loan's interest rate, and on how much risk you can carry. In our example of a ₹40 lakh loan at 8.5% with ₹20,000 to spare each month, a SIP earning a steady 12% ends ₹13.11 lakh ahead after 15 years. Prepaying wins if the fund earns less than about 8.8% a year, or about 9.5% once tax on the gains is counted. Prepaying is certain; the SIP's return is not.

How much sooner does a home loan close if I prepay ₹20,000 a month?

On a ₹40 lakh loan at 8.5% with 15 years left, paying ₹20,000 a month on top of the ₹39,390 EMI closes the loan in 7 years 8 months instead of 15 years, and cuts the interest from ₹30.90 lakh to ₹14.55 lakh.

Is there a penalty for prepaying a home loan?

Banks and housing finance companies cannot charge a prepayment penalty on a floating-rate home loan taken by an individual, under RBI rules. A fixed-rate loan can carry a charge, so check your loan agreement.

Does the tax regime change the answer?

A little. Under the old regime, interest on a loan for a home you live in can be deducted up to ₹2 lakh a year, which lowers the real cost of the loan and makes investing look relatively better. Under the new regime there is no such deduction, so prepaying saves the full interest rate.

Sources: home loan rates published by major banks in October 2026; RBI directions on pre-payment charges on loans; Income-tax Act, 2025 and Finance Act provisions for 2026-27 as summarised in tax publications (interest on a self-occupied home deductible up to ₹2 lakh a year under the old regime only; equity long-term gains 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year); TenX calculations. The loan rate and the fund's return are assumptions for illustration, not forecasts. Figures are rounded.