The loan as it stands
Debjit and Tania Ghosh bought their 2BHK in Behala, Kolkata, five years ago. What remains of the loan is ₹40 lakh at 8.5%, on a floating rate, with 15 years left. The EMI is ₹39,390. If they change nothing, they will pay the bank ₹70.90 lakh over those 15 years: the ₹40 lakh they owe and ₹30.90 lakh of interest.
After the EMI and the household budget, ₹20,000 is left every month. The question is where it should go.
Two roads, the same ₹59,390 a month
On both roads the same amount leaves their account each month: ₹39,390 of EMI plus ₹20,000. Only the destination of the ₹20,000 differs.
Road A: prepay first
₹20,000 extra to the loan
- Loan closed in 7 years 8 months
- Interest paid: ₹14.55 lakh, a saving of ₹16.35 lakh
- Then the whole ₹59,390 goes into a SIP for 7 years 4 months
- ₹82.08 lakh at year 15
Road B: SIP alongside
₹20,000 a month into a SIP
- Loan runs the full 15 years
- Interest paid: ₹30.90 lakh
- 180 instalments of ₹20,000
- ₹95.19 lakh at year 15
Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →
| End of year | Road A: loan left | Road A: fund | Road B: loan left | Road B: fund |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ₹36.12 L | – | ₹38.62 L | ₹2.55 L |
| 3 | ₹27.32 L | – | ₹35.48 L | ₹8.62 L |
| 5 | ₹16.88 L | – | ₹31.77 L | ₹16.22 L |
| 7 | ₹4.52 L | – | ₹27.37 L | ₹25.76 L |
| 8 | Closed | ₹2.52 L | ₹24.87 L | ₹31.40 L |
| 10 | – | ₹19.24 L | ₹19.20 L | ₹44.81 L |
| 12 | – | ₹40.21 L | ₹12.48 L | ₹61.62 L |
| 15 | – | ₹82.08 L | Closed | ₹95.19 L |
Before tax. Fund at an assumed 12% a year, compounded monthly; loan at 8.5% throughout. L = lakh.
Road B ends ₹13.11 lakh ahead. The reason is plain: the SIP is assumed to earn 12% while the loan costs 8.5%, and every rupee that stays invested earns the difference for longer.
The table holds a second thing. In the month Road A makes its last loan payment, 7 years 8 months in, Road B's fund stands at ₹29.45 lakh and its loan at ₹25.73 lakh. Road B could clear its loan that day as well, if it chose to. Until then it has carried a loan and a market risk together.
Prepaying is a sure 8.5%. The SIP is a hoped-for 12%. The whole question is how much that hope is worth to you.
What can go wrong on each road
A steady 12% is an average, not a path. We changed one thing at a time:
Swipe the table sideways to see all columns →
| If… | Road A: prepay first | Road B: SIP alongside |
|---|---|---|
| The fund earns a steady 12% | ₹82.08 L | ₹95.19 L |
| It earns a steady 10% | ₹76.12 L | ₹80.32 L |
| It earns a steady 8% | ₹70.61 L | ₹67.96 L |
| It earns a steady 6% | ₹65.50 L | ₹57.66 L |
| 12%, but markets fall 30% in year 8 | ₹81.54 L | ₹70.02 L |
| 12%, but markets fall 30% in year 15 | ₹52.46 L | ₹59.88 L |
| The loan rate rises to 9.5%, fund at 12% | ₹86.36 L | ₹95.19 L |
Two rows matter most. The first is the break-even: a fund return of about 8.8% a year. Below that, prepaying wins.
The second is the fall in year 8. By then Road B has ₹26 lakh in the market and Road A has nothing there, so the fall hits only one of them, and Road A finishes ₹11.52 lakh ahead. The same fall in year 15 hits both, and Road B stays in front.
There is also a risk no table shows. On Road A the EMI disappears after 7 years 8 months. If one of them loses a job in year 9, there is no loan to service. On Road B the ₹39,390 is due every month for 15 years, whatever happens to their salaries or the market.
Tax moves the line a little
On the fund. Gains on equity funds held for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1.25 lakh a year. If each road sold everything in year 15, Road B would pay about ₹7.24 lakh and Road A about ₹3.56 lakh. Road B's lead shrinks from ₹13.11 lakh to ₹9.43 lakh, and the break-even return rises from 8.8% to about 9.5%. Selling over several years, rather than all at once, would cut both bills.
On the loan. Under the old tax regime, interest on a loan for a home you live in can be deducted, up to ₹2 lakh a year. Debjit and Tania will pay ₹3.35 lakh of interest in the coming year, so at the highest slab the deduction is worth up to ₹62,400 a year. It makes the loan cheaper than 8.5% for as long as they claim it. Under the new regime there is no such deduction and the loan costs the full 8.5%. So prepaying is worth more to a family in the new regime than in the old.
A middle road
They don't have to pick one. If ₹10,000 goes to the loan and ₹10,000 to a SIP, the loan closes in 10 years 1 month, the interest bill is ₹19.66 lakh, and they have ₹86.97 lakh at year 15: between the two roads on every count.
- An emergency fund comes before either. Money prepaid into a loan can't be taken back out when a salary stops. For its first 7 years 8 months, Road A has no savings to fall back on at all.
- Windfalls do the most in the early years. A bonus paid into the loan cuts the most interest while the balance is at its largest. Banks cannot charge a penalty for prepaying a floating-rate home loan taken by an individual.
- Road B only works if the SIP is never skipped. A prepayment happens once and stays done. A SIP has to survive 180 monthly decisions, some of them made in falling markets.
