Two roads to 60
Ishita Roy is 25 and works in Sector V, Kolkata. After rent and a train pass, ₹5,000 a month is what she can spare. Her colleagues tell her to enjoy her twenties and invest "properly" once the salary is bigger. So here are both versions of her, each at an assumed 12% a year:
Road A: start now
₹5,000 a month from 25
- 420 instalments, never stopped
- ₹21 lakh put in by 60
- ₹2.76 crore at 60
Road B: start at 35
₹15,000 a month from 35
- 300 instalments, never stopped
- ₹45 lakh put in by 60
- ₹2.55 crore at 60
Road A puts in less than half the money and still ends ₹20 lakh ahead. Road B never catches up: at 45 it has ₹33.61 lakh against ₹45.99 lakh, and at 55, ₹1.38 crore against ₹1.54 crore.
At 12% a year, ₹21 lakh put in from 25 beats ₹45 lakh put in from 35. The extra ten years do what the extra ₹24 lakh cannot.
Where the ₹2.76 crore comes from
Split Road A's instalments by the decade in which Ishita paid them, and look at what each block is worth at 60:
| Instalments paid at | Put in | Worth at 60 |
|---|---|---|
| 25 to 35 | ₹6.00 L | ₹1.90 Cr |
| 35 to 45 | ₹6.00 L | ₹61.31 L |
| 45 to 55 | ₹6.00 L | ₹19.74 L |
| 55 to 60 | ₹3.00 L | ₹4.06 L |
The first ten years of instalments, ₹6 lakh in all, become ₹1.90 crore: more than two-thirds of everything she has at 60. They are worth ₹11.20 lakh when she turns 35. Then they sit for 25 more years and multiply 17 times.
That is what Road B gives up. It isn't the ₹6 lakh. It is the 25 years that ₹6 lakh would have had.
The price of waiting
Turn the question around. Suppose Ishita wants the same ₹2.76 crore at 60, but starts later. How much does she need every month?
| She starts at | Monthly SIP needed | Put in by 60 |
|---|---|---|
| 25 | ₹5,000 | ₹21.00 L |
| 30 | ₹8,943 | ₹32.20 L |
| 35 | ₹16,187 | ₹48.56 L |
| 40 | ₹29,955 | ₹71.89 L |
| 45 | ₹57,895 | ₹1.04 Cr |
| 50 | ₹1,22,990 | ₹1.48 Cr |
Every five years of waiting roughly doubles the monthly amount. Waiting ten years, to 35, means ₹16,187 a month instead of ₹5,000, and ₹48.56 lakh out of her pocket instead of ₹21 lakh, for exactly the same result.
Where it stops being true
Everything above assumes 12% a year for 35 years, and nobody is promised that. So we ran Ishita's two roads again at other returns:
| If the fund earns | Road A: ₹5,000 from 25 | Road B: ₹15,000 from 35 |
|---|---|---|
| 8% a year | ₹1.08 Cr | ₹1.37 Cr |
| 10% | ₹1.71 Cr | ₹1.86 Cr |
| 11% | ₹2.17 Cr | ₹2.18 Cr |
| 12% | ₹2.76 Cr | ₹2.55 Cr |
| 14% | ₹4.47 Cr | ₹3.52 Cr |
The two roads cross at about 11% a year. Below that, three times the money beats ten extra years. So the popular line, that a small SIP started early always beats a big one started late, holds only when returns are high.
What holds at every one of these returns is the price of waiting. To match Road A from 35, Ishita needs 2.4 times the monthly amount at 8%, 2.8 times at 10% and 3.2 times at 12%.
Starting early doesn't guarantee you beat a bigger, later SIP. It means the same goal costs you far less every month.
The road most people actually take
The choice was never really one or the other. At 25, ₹5,000 is what Ishita has. At 35 she will have more. If she starts with ₹5,000 now and moves to ₹15,000 at 35, she puts in ₹51 lakh and reaches ₹4.46 crore at 60. That is ₹1.90 crore more than Road B, for ₹6 lakh more.
Or she can raise the SIP a little every year as her pay rises. ₹5,000 raised by 5% each year becomes ₹8,144 a month by 35 and ₹26,267 a month by 59, and adds up to ₹4.31 crore at 60.
- Start with what you can spare now. Even ₹1,000 a month from 25 is ₹4.2 lakh put in and about ₹55 lakh at 60, at the same 12%.
- Raise it when your pay rises. A SIP that grows with the salary does the work of both roads.
- Don't stop in the first ten years. Those are the instalments that end up as two-thirds of the total.
